香港司法獨立的爭議
發表於 : 週三 10月 23, 2024 10:38 pm
香港司法獨立的爭議
前最高法院法官約翰·薩姆普頓（Lord Jonathan Sumption）指責香港的司法機構對政府“過於偏袒”，引發關注。他在播客中提到，最近的案件顯示司法機構似乎向政府低頭，特別是在47位民主派人士案中有14人被定罪的情況下。
薩姆普頓還提到《立場新聞》的煽動罪判決，認為在一個合理的自由社會中，報紙編輯應該可以批評政府，這是言論自由的基石。
政府否認這些指控，強調香港的司法獨立性和法治未有惡化。
Controversy Over Judicial Independence in Hong Kong
Former top court judge Lord Jonathan Sumption criticized the Hong Kong Judiciary for being "too partial" to the authorities. In a recent podcast, he noted that recent cases suggest the Judiciary is kowtowing to the government, especially with 14 out of 16 pro-democracy figures convicted in the 47 democrats case.
Sumption also commented on the Stand News sedition verdict, arguing that newspaper editors should be free to criticize the government, a fundamental aspect of free speech.
The government denies these claims, insisting on the independence of Hong Kong's judiciary and that the rule of law has not deteriorated.
#香港 #JudicialIndependence #人權 #HumanRights #言論自由 #FreeSpeech #法治 #RuleOfLaw #政治迫害 #PoliticalPersecution
https://hongkongfp.com/2024/10/22/hong- ... thorities/
前最高法院法官約翰·薩姆普頓（Lord Jonathan Sumption）指責香港的司法機構對政府“過於偏袒”，引發關注。他在播客中提到，最近的案件顯示司法機構似乎向政府低頭，特別是在47位民主派人士案中有14人被定罪的情況下。
薩姆普頓還提到《立場新聞》的煽動罪判決，認為在一個合理的自由社會中，報紙編輯應該可以批評政府，這是言論自由的基石。
政府否認這些指控，強調香港的司法獨立性和法治未有惡化。
Controversy Over Judicial Independence in Hong Kong
Former top court judge Lord Jonathan Sumption criticized the Hong Kong Judiciary for being "too partial" to the authorities. In a recent podcast, he noted that recent cases suggest the Judiciary is kowtowing to the government, especially with 14 out of 16 pro-democracy figures convicted in the 47 democrats case.
Sumption also commented on the Stand News sedition verdict, arguing that newspaper editors should be free to criticize the government, a fundamental aspect of free speech.
The government denies these claims, insisting on the independence of Hong Kong's judiciary and that the rule of law has not deteriorated.
#香港 #JudicialIndependence #人權 #HumanRights #言論自由 #FreeSpeech #法治 #RuleOfLaw #政治迫害 #PoliticalPersecution
https://hongkongfp.com/2024/10/22/hong- ... thorities/